shyscyberchamber.com  
UNSOLVED CRIMES

Date Added

The Disappearance of Good Time Joe February 2003
  With a leggy showgirl on his arm, Judge Joseph Crater stepped out of a plush nightclub on New York's 45th Street and hailed a taxi.  He gave his companion an affectionate squeeze and a kiss on the cheek.  'See you tomorrow Ruby,' said the Judge, whose unorthodox social life had earned him the nickname, Goodtime Joe.  But he didn't.  A little later, he was seen buying a theatre ticket for the Broadway hit, Dancing Partners.


From that moment, on 6th August, Judge Joseph Crater vanished, and it happened so mysteriously and in such politically scandalous circumstances that in America 'pulling a Crater' is sometimes still used to describe a baffling disappearance.  In New York, he is still officially listed as missing, although he would now be 93 years old, and the police department still checks regular reports of sightings.


Judge Crater was a sentimental family man - and a womanizer on a grand scale.  He was a pillar of society, yet he enjoyed the company of rogues.  He believed fervently in the sanctity of the law but became part of the most corrupt administration in New York's history.  He had been a brilliant professor of law at New York University, but he wanted to be rich.  As a lawyer with an obvious interest in making money, he was welcomed by the city's then shady administration.  In the summer of 1929 he acted as a receiver when the bankrupt Libby Hotel was sole to a finance company for $75,000.  Six weeks later, the hotel resold to the city of New York to be demolished in a road widening scheme.  The price: $2,800,000.  Many members of the administration, including Crater, mad a lot of money from the deal.


By 1930, he had the lifestyle of a very rich man.  More good fortune came his way when Franklin D Roosevelt, then Governor of New York State, made him a justice of the city's Supreme Court.  Crater had finally made it.  He was rich and powerful.  Then, on the evening of 2nd August, something happened to threaten his cozy world.


He was on holiday with his wife at their summer cottage in Maine when he received a mysterious phone call.  It was enough to send the Judge hurrying back to New York.  'I've got to straighten some fellow's out', was all he told his wife, promising to return for her birthday a week later.  She never saw him again.


In New York on 6th August he wrote two cheques for a total of $4,100 and sent his assistant Joe Mara, to the bank to cash them.  When Mara returned, Cater had stuffed papers from his office files into four large portfolios and two briefcases.  He told Mara he was going 'up Westchester way for a few days'.


That evening, however, he turned up at his favourite nightclub on 45th Street, but after a few drinks, with showgirl Ruby Ritz he left, saying he was going to the theatre.


Amazingly, it was four weeks and a day before the disappearance of one of the city's top judges finally leaked out.  Friends and enemies alike, terrified at the idea of a scandal which might implement them, were desperate to hush up the affair.  Manhattan District Attorney, Thomas Crain, was anxious to question Mrs Crater.  She refused to talk and the judge's politically powerful friends kept Crain at bay.


Soon, reports of alleged sightings were coming in from around the world. 


In 1955 a photograph of Crater was shown to the Dutch clairvoyant Gerard Croiset.  He claimed that the judge had been murdered on the first floor of a farmhouse near the Bronx, New York and his body buried in the garden.

BACK TO TOP





Check out
the latest
Crypt Polls!
 


 

-»¦«-

F o u n d   a   b r  o k e n   l  i n k ?   L e t   u  s   k n o w