|
|
Hawley Harvey Crippen was the son of a respectable
family from Coldwater, Michigan. His grandfather, Philo, ran the
local dry goods store, building up the business to be inherited by
Hawley's father, Myron. Coldwater grew from a cluster of log
cabins to a thriving town and the Crippen family grew with it.
By the time of Hawley's birth in 1862, the store and house were the
biggest in town.
Hawley was an only child and, coming from the richest family in town,
he grew up spoilt and conceited. From his childhood, he was set
on emulating his Uncle Bradley, Coldwater's family physician.
Hawley attended the local school during the week, and read the Bible
on Sunday.
His family - and especially his grandfather - were devout Christians,
following a grim, strict and unforgiving Protestantism. After
chapel, where the family sat in the front pew every Sunday, Philo
Crippen took his grandson on his knee, and sternly read him long
passages from the Old Testament, drumming the Books of Proverbs and
Isaiah, with their emphasis on the 'sins of flesh', into the young
child, whose curiosity was aroused by the phrase.
Crippen paid his way through university by working as an assistant in
a chemistry laboratory at the University of Michigan's School of
Homeopathy where he obtained a diploma. He qualified as a doctor
at the Homeopathic Hospital in Cleveland, Ohio. It was not,
however, a qualification that would have allowed him to practice in
England without taking further examinations. |
 |
CHARLOTTE BELL :
Charlotte Bell, Crippen's first wife, was born in Dublin and went to
America as a student nurse. The marriage did not last.
Crippen found her religion a burden. Divorce was out of the
question but, conveniently, for Crippen, she died. |
|
|
Crippen sailed for England in 1883 to continue his
medical studies at St Thomas's and Guy's Hospitals. He also
attended lectures on mental disorders at the Bethlehem Royal Hospital,
an asylum that had become popularly known as 'Bedlam'.
Crippen then returned to New York, where he obtained a diploma from
the Opthalmic Hospital in 1885. It was while he was doing his
internship at the Hahnemann Hospital in Manhattan, New York, that he
met and married Charlotte Jane Bell, then a student nurse.
The marriage seems to have been a failure. Charlotte, originally
from Ireland, was born and brought up in a convent, and remained
strongly Catholic all her life. She even had to get a special
dispensation to marry Crippen as he was a Protestant.
Crippen's excitement at finally discovering 'the sins of the flesh'
quickly palled, with his wife visiting confessional every time they
slept together.
They travelled west to San Diego where, in 1888, Charlotte gave birth
to a boy, Otto Hawley Crippen. Then four years later, after a
journey to Salt Lake City, Charlotte died of apoplexy in the bitter
cold of a Utah January. She had been due to give birth a few
days later.
Otto was sent to live with his grandparents in San Jose, California,
while Crippen returned to New York, and opened a new practice.
It was six months later in July 1892, at his Brooklyn surgery, that
Crippen first met his second wife. Kunigunde Mackamotzki, by
then known as Cora Turner, was a bright 19 year old, of mixed European
stock - her father, who had died when she was two years old, was a
Russian Polish grocer, and her mother was German. |
 |
AURAL
REMEDIES :
Crippen discarded whatever medical principles he had when he and Cora
faced financial ruin. Using his skills as an ear specialist, he
set up in a fraudulent company, offering fake remedies for ear
infections. |
|
|
To the prematurely balding, 30 year old widower, she
was a creature to be nurtured and protected, and it did not bother him
that she was a 'kept woman'. She was impetuous, and her
ruggedness and good humour appealed to him. In sharp contrast,
Cora loved him for his distinguished air, his dependability and the
security he offered - she came from immigrant stock and a man with a
profession, such as a doctor or lawyer, was highly respected.
After a brief, six week courtship, they married on 1st September 1892,
in New Jersey. But from the first, things went awry.
Almost immediately, Cora had to have an operation to remove her
ovaries, which may have been due to complications from a miscarriage.
Now, to the deep disappointment of them both, she could not have
children.
The early 1890's was a period of economic unrest in America as a great
depression took hold, with vast numbers of people living rough.
Homeopathic and conventional medicine alike were under financial
strain. Doctor's bills went unpaid as the breadlines formed in
the cities. Cora was forced to abandon the operatic singing
lessons she had been taking since childhood and, for a time, Crippen
had to move in with her family.
The sharp-witted Cora soon realised that the New York public simply
did not have the money for homeopathic remedies and she persuaded her
husband to sacrifice his principles to become a quack.
Crippen began to sell patent remedies, and soon joined up with another
quack doctor, 'Professor' Munyon, running the offices of his
Homeopathic Remedies on East 14th Street, Manhattan. Cora also
worked there as a cashier, and the couple were forced to sleep in a
room above the office.
Within a year, Crippen - described by Munyon as 'one of the most
intelligent men I ever knew' - was promoted to general manager at the
head office in Philadelphia. He went on to open Munyon's new
office in Toronto. |
 |
CORA TURNER & HAWLEY CRIPPEN :
Cora Turner became Crippen's second wife within weeks of meeting him. |
|
|
When Crippen returned to Philadelphia, Cora left almost
at once for New York, where she wanted to continue her singing career.
In 1897, Crippen was offered the London office at a salary equivalent
to $10,000 a year. Cora joined him after four months, hinting
that she had had shipboard romances on the journey.
Cora had pretensions to opera, and had switched to vaudeville.
She called herself Belle Elmore, and because American acts were all
the rage, she managed to find middle-of-the-bill work, earning about
£3 a week before expenses.
However, Cora's London debut, under her new stage name of Macka Motzki,
at the Old Marylebone Music Hall, ended in failure after a week and
her contract was not renewed. She was also putting on weight and
was known unkindly as 'The Brooklyn Matzoh Ball' (after a dumpling
eaten during the Jewish Passover). She began to blame Crippen
for her lack of success.
She was not entirely fair to her husband. He had been neglecting
Munyon's business to promote his wife when, out of the blue, he was
recalled to Philadelphia. Munyon had discovered that Crippen had
been described as 'Acting Manager' on a handbill for Vio and Motzki's
American Bright Lights Company. As a result, he was sacked. |
 |
VIO & MOTZKI'S AMERICAN BRIGHT LIGHTS COMPANY :
Cora wanted to be an operatic
prima donna, but her voice was not up to it. She became a music-hall
entertainer. At her London debut, Crippen was billed as her Acting
Manager. |
|
|
There was worse to come. The Crippen marriage was
now in ruins. Cora had taken up with a former prize-fighter,
Bruce Miller, now on the music-hall circuit. Even worse, she had
developed a taste for drink - as well as an ungovernable temper.
It could never be said that Crippen was not a worker. First, he
joined another patent pill company, which went bust within a year,
then he tried to market his own remedy named 'Amorette'.
He set Cora up as a 'minituare painter' at their newer and cheaper
flat in Store Street, near the British Museum, and in 1901 he joined
the Drouet Institute, which prescribed patent plasters to be stuck
behind the ears as a cure for deafness.
The firm spent the then enormous sum of between £20,000 and
£30,000 a year on advertising
what was later described as 'one of the biggest and most ambitious
frauds on the deaf ever engineered in this country'. It was at
the Drouet Institute, in 1902, that Crippen first set eyes on Ethel Le
Neve. |
 |
ETHEL LE NEVE :
Ethel Le Neve, initially unsure of Crippen's marital status, progressed from
being his secretary to his mistress. |
|
|
Ethel Le Neve met Dr Crippen when she was 17. She
lived at home in Camden Town, London, where her family name was Neve -
like Cora with her stage name of Belle Elmore, Ethel had made the
French alteration as an affectation. As a child, she had been a
tomboy preferred playing with a catapult to dolls.
She went train-spotting with an uncle and took a great interest in
locomotive engines. She was a hypochondriac - her nickname was
'Not-Very-Well-Thank-You' She was also a persistent liar and had
a very domineering personality. Her sister, Nina, worked at the
Druoet Institute for the Deaf, where Crippen was employed as
'consultant physician'.
The institute was named after an alcoholic Frenchman who had developed
plasters which, when placed behind the ears, were claimed to cure
deafness.
Crippen must have known that the claims were completely false and that
the treatment was just a money-making racket. However, Crippen
needed the money, not so much for himself. but for his demanding and
big-spending wife.
When Nina left the institute to get married, Ethel replaced her as
Crippen's private secretary. Despite later claims that Crippen
seduced Ethel and that she was clay in his hands, it seems more likely
that Ethel saw in Crippen someone she could manipulate. Both
people with deeply unpleasant traits, they seemed made for each other.
Nevertheless, it was not until seven years after they had first met
that they slept together. |
 |
39 HILLDROP CRESCENT :
After the events of 1910, 39 Hilldrop Crescent was rented out by its owner to a
Scottish comedian named Sandy McNab, who planned to convert it into small flats
for people in the acting profession. The venture failed, and the house
remained empty, gradually falling into disrepair.
McNab then tried to turn the house into a Crippen museum, but after protests
from local residents, the Scotsman abandoned his schemes.
The house was finally destroyed during World War II, when it suffered a direct
hit by a German bomb. On its site, there now stands a block of flats
called Margaret Bondfield House, named after Britain's first woman Cabinet
Minister. |
|
|
Ethel developed an instant crush on the doctor.
She did not know he was a married man. She later recalled that
'Dr Crippen was leading a somewhat isolated life. I did not knew
whether he was married or not. Certainly he never spoke of his
wife.' But she found out soon enough when Cora arrived at the
office in a bad temper. Ethel described the event: 'Her coming
was of a somewhat stormy character... She was obviously angry about
something.' More scenes followed during subsequent visits and it
became clear to Ethel why the doctor had been so reluctant to talk
about his private life.
Ethel provided the refuge from his marriage, which was crumbling
rapidly. Cora's extravagance and selfishness had increased since
her lover, Bruce Miller, had returned to the United States.
Despite the fact that Crippen had supplied her with virtually anything
she wanted - including a collection of jewellery that was the envy of
her friends - she had absolutely no respect for him. When he
explained to her that he was in financial difficulties, her reaction
was to go out at once and buy a new wardrobe of clothes.
Although she had failed in her dreams to become a music-hall star,
Cora compensated for this with her boundless social energy. She
was, in fact, considerably liked for her vitality, warm nature and
down-to-earth openness - so much so that some of the top names in
music hall, all women, sought her company. |
 |
CORA CRIPPEN :
Cora Crippen, stage name Belle Elmore, wanted to be an opera singer.
Though she made her London debut in an operetta, it failed badly and she
gradually found herself playing 'middle of the bill' acts in music hall.
She blamed her failure on Crippen, who she said did not encourage her. |
|
|
The women, including Marie Lloyd, would meet on a weekly basis to
drink tea and gossip. It was one of these social gatherings,
when the plight of Flora Linton was mentioned, that the Music Hall
Ladies' Guild was born. Flora had entered a sanatorium to be
treated for tuberculosis, leaving behind a blond husband to look after
their two children. The party of women decided to step in and
help.
The Guild allowed Cora to indulge
her forceful personality in fund-raising activities and gave her a
legitimate role among the theatre folk she loved. They returned
her affection, but did not extend it to her husband. They
regarded him as a sponger. Marie Lloyd even went so far as to
nickname him 'The Half Crown King', as he never had any money and
would always asked to borrow half-a-crown.
The Crippens by this time moved to 39 Hilldrop Crescent. After
the small flat they had occupied, the new home meant that Crippen and
his wife no longer had to share a bedroom. There were many
visitors to Hilldrop Crescent, mostly Cora's friends, all of whom
noticed how quiet and unassuming Dr Crippen was in comparison to his
loud wife. There was no question in any of their friends' minds
about who the dominant partner in the relationship was.
In 1906, Cora advertised for paying guests at Hilldrop Crescent so
that she would have something to do to occupy herself. Four
German students came to stay, one of whom, William Ehrlich, became a
particular favourite of Cora's. Ehrlich noticed the degree of
degradation that Crippen suffered at the hands of his wife. For
example, Crippen had to clean the house and the lodger's shoes before
they got up in the morning. |
|
|
The police visit in early July convinced Crippen that
he and Ethel had to get away. The reason he gave to Ethel was
that the neighbours, particularly the Music Hall Ladies' Guild, would
start to gossip. He doubted he could face the office staff again
now that he knew the police had been to see him. Their lives
would be a misery. They must go away and start a new life.
Chief Inspector Dew had spoken to Ethel on her own and had told her of
Crippen's admission that Cora's death had been a lie. She was
angry that Crippen had told her a direct lie for the first time, but
she seemed to accept that he did not know where Cora was.
It was while they were still at Hilldrop Crescent that the two of them
decided that Ethel should travel disguised as a boy. Crippen has
been described as a cold-blooded and ruthless murderer, but his
plotting did not work well in this case and was comic rather than
calculating. He roughly cut off Ethel's hair, and sent one of
his employees out to buy a boy's suit. It was too small, and
Ethel split the trousers the moment she put them on. |
 |
ETHEL LE NEVE / MASTER JOHN ROBINSON :
Ethel Le Neve, photographed after her arrest, in the outfit she wore when she
left the country as Master John Robinson. |
|
|
Crippen and Ethel never returned to Hilldrop Crescent.
Arranging to leave the office separately, they met at Chancery Lane
tube station and then went on to Liverpool Street station to catch the
train to Harwich.
They caught the night boat to Holland. In Rotterdam, Crippen
took Ethel to have her hair cut properly. By this time, he had
shaved off his moustache. Ethel had left her bowler hat on the
boat and so a new straw one had to be bought for her. They went
on to Brussels, where they stayed for ten days at the Hotel des
Ardennes.
At first Crippen planned to return to England and get a boat from Hull
to America. He then saw an advertisement for boats sailing from
Antwerp to Quebec and booked two second class berths, sailing on 31st
July 1910. But on 15th July, he saw in the Belgian newspapers
that the remains of Cora had been discovered and that the search was
on for himself and Ethel. He returned straight to the booking
office and changed the tickets to the earlier sailing on 20th July.
They travelled on the SS Montrose under the assumed names of John
Philo Robinson and Master John Robinson.
They tried to be as unobtrusive as possible, but inevitably had to mix
with the other passengers and the crew, including sharing dinner with
the master of the Montrose, Captain Henry Kendall. It did not
occur to Crippen that, by dressing Ethel up as a boy, they had made
the fatal blunder in their attempt to escape. |
 |
SS MONTROSE & CAPTAIN KENDALL :
Captain Kendall (inset), skipper of the Montrose, became suspicious of two of
his passengers. He thought they looked remarkably like the couple wanted
for murder. |
|
|
The Crippen case reached its dramatic climax 11 days
after the lovers had set sail from a port in Belgium. The couple
travelled on a cargo ship that carried passengers as well. They
were pursued by Chief Inspector Dew, on board one of a new generation
of steamships that was much faster than the cargo ship, and which cut
the Atlantic crossing time by as much as three days.
20th JULY: Crippen and Le Neve, disguised as a young man,
boarded the Montrose at Antwerp bound for Quebec, Canada. The
couple were registered as Mr and Master Robinson.
22nd JULY: Captain Kendall sent radio message about Crippen and
Le Neve to the ship's owners who then passed it on to Scotland Yard.
23rd JULY: Sea chase started as Chief Inspector Dew left
Liverpool on board the Laurentic. British newspapers reported
that Dew's ship was gaining on the Montrose at the rate of 5.6km (3
1/2 miles) per hour.
25th JULY: Radio message sent to the Montrose from a London
newspaper confirming that Scotland Yard had received a radio message
about Crippen.
27th JULY: The Laurentic overtook the Montrose.
31st JULY: Crippen and Le Neve arrested at Father Point in
Canandian waters. Both were jailed in Montreal pending
extradition proceedings. |
 |
SS MEGANTIC :
A crowd at Liverpool docks watches as the SS Megantic, carrying Crippen and Le
Neve from Canada, is towed in to harbour in August 1910. The Megantic was
a sister ship of the White Star liner SS Laurentic which took Chief Inspector
Dew on his transatlantic chase. |
|
|
Captain Henry Kendall did not get a chance to introduce
himself to the two passengers, John Philo Robinson and his son John,
until the Montrose was out at sea. It immediately struck him
that there was something odd about the couple. The boy's figure
was strange - broad hips, small feet and delicate white hands.
Kendall also noticed that, although the father was not wearing
spectacles, he had the red marks on either side of the bridge of his
nose that were the giveaway sign of someone who normally wore them.
Kendall invited the pair to share lunch at his table and, during the
meal, found an excuse to go to their cabin and make a search. He
noticed that they had only a single suitcase between them and that the
boy did not even possess an overcoat for the journey.
Later on that same day, Kendall went to look at a back copy of the
Daily Mail, dated 14th July, which carried photographs of Dr Hawley
Harvey Crippen and Ethel Le Neve. By closely examining the faces
in each picture, Kendall became convinced that the two passengers he
had just met were wanted in connection with the murder of Cora Crippen
in London.
The following morning, Kendall took the Chief Officer into his
confidence. When they were 208km (130 miles) west of the Lizard
promontory, on the English coast, Captain Kendall handed the radio
operator the message that was to lead to one of the most publicised
sea chases of all time. |
 |
CAPTAIN HENRY KENDALL :
Captain Henry Kendal was suspicious of the father and son travelling on his
ship. He relayed his fears in a wireless message which was sent to the
ship's owners based in Liverpool. |
|
|
The telegram which told of Kendall's suspicions, was passed from
the Liverpool ship owners to Scotland Yard, where it came into the hands of
Chief Inspector Walter Dew. For Dew it was the break he had desperately
needed. It had been ten days since the discovery of Cora Crippen's body,
and as every day passed it had seemed increasingly likely that Crippen and Le
Neve would manage to get away.
By taking the White Star liner Laurentic, which left from Liverpool the
following day, there was a good chance that Dew would arrive in Quebec ahead of
Crippen. Although the Montrose had a three day start, the Laurentic's
running time was four days shorter. Dew persuaded his superior, the
Assistant Commissioner, Sir Melville Macnaghten, that Captain Kendall's telegram
was worth acting on and, after receiving his written authorisation, he left
London for Liverpool. There, Chief Inspector Dew boarded the Laurentic,
travelling under the assumed name of Dewhurst.
Initially, there was doubt about the reliability of Captain Kendall's judgement.
Chief Inspector Dew was taking a risk of major public embarrassment if he
arrived in Canada to find that he had been chasing the wrong couple. The
police code name given to his journey was 'Operation Handcuffs' and it began in
utmost secrecy. Even Dew's wife was not told of the purpose of her
husband's journey before he left for Liverpool.
The police became confident that they had made the right decision after
photographs of Ethel Le Neve and Crippen were positively identified by the
travel agent who had booked their passage aboard the Montrose in Antwerp. |
 |
WEEKLY DISPATCH :
Crippen and Le Neve were unaware that
they were making headline news in Britain. Readers, such as those of the
Weekly Dispatch, learnt how Crippen spent his days on deck, sometimes he would
comment on the marvel of wireless telegraphy - not realising that he was the
subject of the messages being sent. |
|
|
Captain Kendall, in the meantime, had made good use of the
Marconi wireless system on board the ship to pass back a stream of reports about
the couple to the Daily Mail and other newspapers. The public learned from
Kendall that 'Crippen was growing a beard and looking more like a farmer every
day,' and that everything Ethel did made it more and more obvious that she was a
girl.
Kendall was also kept busy making sure that neither Crippen nor Ethel became
suspicious that they had been recognised.
'They have been under strict observation all the voyage, as, if they smelt a
rat, he might do something rash,' Captain Kendall relayed to the press.
He went around the ship removing all the English papers that mentioned anything
about the murder. At the same time, Kendall tried to obtain further small
items of proof as to the couple's real identity. He would call them as
they walked on deck, using their assumed names, to see how slow they were to
recognise them. On several occasions, it was only Ethel who turned to the
Captain, and then apologised, saying the cold weather had made Dr Crippen go
slightly deaf.
Kendall had also read the newspapers that Crippen had lived in San Francisco,
Detroit and Toronto. By bringing these cities up in conversation, he
confirmed that John Philo Robinson was familiar with these places. |
 |
CHIEF INSPECTOR DEW :
Chief Inspector Dew (centre) going through the formalities of Crippen's arrest
on board the Montrose. It took three weeks before Crippen could set sail
on the Megantic to face trial in London. |
|
|
Crippen and Ethel Le Neve were unaware of the fact the attention
of the world's press was being focused on their transatlantic journey to Canada.
Ethel was confident that her identity remained hidden. 'It never entered
my head,' she wrote afterwards, 'that the ship's officers had discovered my
disguise.' To keep up pretences, she made friends with one of the boys on
board the Montrose.
For most of the journey, Crippen was relaxed and seemingly confident about the
future. Only once were his suspicions raised. when he overheard the
wireless operator sending a dispatch. When he asked who the message was
for, the wireless operator quickly said that he was asking the skipper of
another ship whether any ice had been spotted near where they were heading.
Two days later, before the Montrose was due to reach Father Point, a lonely
pilot station on the St Lawrence River, Crippen's optimism left him. He
gave Ethel all their money, telling her that he might have to leave her when
they reached Canada. He suggested that she should go to Toronto and get a
job as a secretary.
She interpreted this as meaning Crippen would go ahead to find them somewhere to
live. But his intentions seemed to be different. After his arrest, a
note was found on the back of a visiting car that he had printed in Brussels in
the name of John Robinson: 'I can't stand the horror I go through every night
any longer, and as I see nothing bright ahead and money has come to an end, I
have made up my mind to jump overboard tonight. I know I have spoiled your
life, but I hope that some day you can learn to forgive me. With last
words of love. Your H.' |
 |
THE RETURN OF CRIPPEN :
Crippen, his face partly hidden by his
coat's upturned collar, disembarks at Liverpool, with Chief Inspector Dew at his
side. A large, hostile crowd was waiting for him. |
|
|
At his trial, Crippen denied he intended to commit suicide, which
itself was a criminal offence. He said that a friendly quartermaster had
agreed to stow him away when the ship reached Montreal, and that the note would
throw Dew of his trail.
By the time the Montrose reached Father Point, the chase was over. Chief
Inspector Dew had already arrived and, disguised as a pilot in a brass-buttoned
jacket and visored cap, was waiting to go aboard. While journalists stood
by on a nearby pilot boat, Dew and a number of Canadian policemen approached
Crippen.
'Good morning, Dr Crippen,' said Dew. Crippen's face showed puzzlement,
then he recognised the officer who had interviewed him only weeks before.
He asked what he was being arrested for, and then grabbed the warrant from one
of the policemen. 'Murder and mutilation. Oh, God,' he said, before
being manacled.
After spending 19 days in prison in the city of Quebec, Crippen and Ethel were
brought back to England by Dew on the SS Megantic. They were kept separate
during the voyage, except on one brief occasion, when Dew allowed them to gaze
at each other, in poignant silence, from the doorways of their respective
cabins. |
 |
HAWLEY HARVEY CRIPPEN :
Hawley Harvey Crippen has been described as 'mild-mannered', but when the
conflicts within himself became too much, he chose a course of action - murder -
that belied his image. |
|
|
Crippen was quite used to being the weak partner in the
relationship between himself and Cora.
Psychologically, he was the archetypal hen-pecked husband. He was
weak-willed, long-suffering and prepared to go to extremes of generosity to
ensure that his wife stayed with him. There was something masochistic
about this behaviour. But, once he no longer had to oblige Cora sexually,
he was free to look elsewhere. He took a mistress who would eventually
provide the ingredient that would fire him up with a hatred strong enough to
drive him to murder his wife.
This ingredient came out of his love for Ethel and his protectiveness towards
her. When Cora Crippen began to apply the same scorn to Crippen's mistress
as had been dealt out to himself, the emotional balance began to tip
dramatically.
Crippen had been in love with Ethel Le Neve for some time. They had
frequently talked about the possibility of his divorcing Cora, but the social
stigma attached to such an action was sufficiently strong to stop them from
going ahead. Dr Crippen, after all, had something of a social position in
Holloway, and risked the possibility of losing his job. In this respect,
his final resort to murder was fashioned as much by social pressures as by his
own feelings.
When Cora Crippen began to make disparaging remarks about Ethel in front of him
and her friends, it became clear that the situation would have to change. |
 |
ETHEL LE NEVE :
Ethel Le Neve was in her late teens when she fell in love with the 41 year old
Crippen. They maintained their romantic involvement (unconsummated for
seven years) despite his marriage to Cora. Ethel always hoped he would
divorce Cora. |
|
|
Dr Crippen found that he was contending with two overwhelming
emotions simultaneously - his love for Ethel and his hatred for his wife.
He was driven to find another option which, if successful, would solve all his
problems at once.
Another motive for murder was given by the prosecution during the trial - that
Crippen needed money. The couple had a joint account and Cora had given
the bank notice that she was going to withdraw all the funds. Crippen may
have suspected she was going to run away. Then, too, there was the speed
with which Crippen had pawned Cora's jewellery after Ethel Le Neve had moved in
with him.
Add to this the fact that Crippen's own job was running into difficulties.
However, the money angle does not make very much sense. The £175 he raised
through pawning Cora's jewellery seems slight compared to his earning power - a
very comfortable £2,500 a year.
Crippen defence during the trial was a blanket denial that the body found in the
coal cellar at 39 Hilldrop Crescent was that of his wife. The reason he
took this course was almost certainly to protect Ethel Le Neve at all costs from
the risk of being prosecuted successfully as an accomplice. As a result,
the exact truth of why Crippen murdered his wife - and why on that particular
night - will never be known.
However, the reasons can be pieced together with some certainty. Most
obvious of all is the state of deterioration that Crippen's marriage had reached
by the beginning of 1910. Cora Crippen had become a drinking, nagging,
domineering, bossy and unfaithful wife. She ridiculed her husband in
public and admitted that she scorned him as a partner. This portrait of
Cora supplied what Chief Inspector Dew favoured as the prime motive for
Crippen's action : sheer hatred. |
 |
CRIPPEN AT TRIAL :
Crippen in the dock at the Old Bailey. He was found guilty and sentenced
to hang. Four days later, Ethel Le Neve appeared in the same dock for her
trial. |
|
|
Throughout the sea voyage back to England, Dr Crippen seemed only
concerned with Ethel Le Neve's welfare. To Chief Inspector Dew, he
insisted on her innocence. When they arrived at Liverpool docks on 28th
August 1910, a large, threatening crowd was waiting for them.
Chief Inspector Dew brought Crippen down the gangplank first, when a young man,
waving a cane, launched himself at Crippen and had to be pulled away by the
police. Ethel Le Neve followed, wearing a blue veil. They caught the
2.20pm train to London. At Euston station, they were met by more jeering
crowds. before being driven to Bow Street police station.
The next day, Travers Humphreys appearing for the Director of Public
Prosecutions, asked that the pair be remanded in custody for one week.
Crippen already had a solicitor, Arthur Newton, who had volunteered to defend
Crippen while he was still awaiting exrtadition in Canada.
Crippen had agreed willingly, not knowing the real intentions behind Newton's
offer. Newton took on Crippen as a 'professional speculation', which would
enable him to pay off his racing debts. He saw Crippen's trial as an
opportunity to enhance his own reputation and also make money.
Newton was already renowned as a dishonest solicitor. Five years before,
he had been jailed for six weeks for attempting to persuade certain key trial
witnesses to leave the country. It was an enormous piece of ill fortune
for Crippen. Properly defended, he might just have escaped the gallows.
As it was, by a combination of Newton and his own pigheadedness, he had no
chance. |
 |
HAWLEY CRIPPEN & ETHEL LE NEVE :
Crippen and Ethel Le Neve stand together in the dock at the Bow Street Court, in
central London, for the committal proceedings in September 1910. The
charge against Ethel was reduced from murder to being an accessory after the
fact. |
|
|
It was also bad luck for Crippen that Edward Marshall Hall, the
oustanding defending barrister of his generation, was away on holiday.
Newton had approached Hall's clerk, but they disagreed over how Marshall Hall
was to be paid.
Given the celebrity of the case, it is likely that Marshall Hall would have
reached some sort of compromise if he had been there. Instead, Newton
walked straight out of his clerk's office and ten minutes later was briefing
another solicitor, Alfred Tobin. Unfortunately for Crippen, Tobin lacked
any of the flair and experience that might have been provided by Marshall Hall.
Tobin had another problem. Crippen seemed to have a death wish. He
was receiving a ver bad press - everyone was convinced that he was guilty and he
was doing nothing to help himself. But he did have the beginnings of a
defence. All he really had to do was admit to everything except the
murder, making the most of Cora Crippen's infidelity, bad temper and drinking
habits.
With a strong defence barrister, there was the possibility of a manslaughter
verdict, or even a defence on the grounds of an accident. But he still
insisted that teh body found in the coal cellar at Hilldrop Crescent was not
that of his wife.
This was the central issue in the case. The defence's forensic team, which
included Doctors Wall and Turnbull, claimed that a piece of the victim's skin
marked with a scar came from the thigh and not the abdomen. If it had been
the latter, it would have corresponded to a scar left by surgery on Cora
Crippen, probably made when her ovaries were removed, making it likely that the
remains were those of Cora. The defence thought they had scored a victory
with this detail.
However, the leader of the prosecution's forensic team, pathologist Bernard
Spilsbury, happened to be an expert in scar tissue. He claimed the skin
came from the abdomen, and was proved correct when some abdominal muscle tissue
was found still attached to the skin. |
 |
CRIPPEN & THE MEDIA :
Crippen bitterly resented the lies
printed in a hostile press and took particular exception when some newspapers
wrongly claimed that he had made a confession. |
|
|
Added to this evidence was the poison found in the remains.
Crippen had signed the Poisons Register for hyoscine, highly poisonous crystals,
only a matter of days before his wife's disappearance. But what the
prosecution really needed was to establish that the pyjama top wrapped around
the remains belonged to Crippen.
Chief Inspector Dew, after his return from Canada, had to be chased to produce
the necessary evidence regarding the pyjama top. He eventually came up
with the precise details. This was probably the most serious blow to the
defence as Crippen did have a similar pair of pyjamas and the top was missing.
Crippen claimed that he had lost the top prior to moving into Hilldrop Crescent
in 1905.
But detectives had been thorough in their work - they established that the
pyjama top, with its Jones Brothers label, identifying a large Holloway
retailer, could only have been bought in 1909, when Crippen was already living
at Hilldrop Crescent. Crippen could not explain this away and it became
crucial to the prosecution's case.
Over 4000 applications were received for seats for the trial and 700 were
granted. The trial opened at the Old Bailey on Tuesday 18th October 1910.
It had already been decided that Ethel should have seperate counsel for her
trial, which was to follow immediately after Crippen's.
The medical evidence was secure. Bernand Spilsbury, who was to become the
greatest pathologist of his era, was at the start of his career. He was
able to show that the scar on the 20cm (eight inch) long piece of skin found in
the coal cellar was, in fact, from the abdomen - the result of an ovarian
removal operation. |
 |
CROWDS OUTSIDE THE OLD BAILEY :
The much publicised sea chase and the arrest of Crippen had caught the public
imagination. By the time he appeared at the Old Baily, crowds gathered in
hope of catching a glimpse of the man who had dismembered his wife's body. |
|
|
Crippen did as well as could be expected in the witness box.
He stood up well to the relentless cross-examination. But he could not
explain where his wife had gone, nor how the body, whose death occurred after
the Crippen's had moved in, found its way into his cellar. The newspapers
were enthusiastic about his performance. 'Marvellous exhibition of nerve
power,' said the Daily Mail, but it was of no help. On the fourth day, the
jury retired and returned after only twenty seven minutes of consideratrion to
find Crippen guilty of wilful murder.
Lord Chief Justice Alverstone decided not to dwell on the 'ghastly and wicked
nature of the crime'. After the judge's marshal had placed the black cap
on his head, Lord Alverstone ordered that Hawley Harvey Crippen be 'taken from
hence to a lawful prison, and from thence to a place of execution, and that you
there be hanged by the neck until you are dead'.
Crippen showed no emotion. When asked if he had anything to say, he
replied, 'I still protest my innocence.'
The trial of Ethel Le Neve, which opened on Tuesday 25th October, in the same
courtroom was very different. She was represented by the outstanding F. E.
Smith, who later became Lord Birkenhead. In contrast to the plodding
Tobin, Smith's was a brilliant performance. He made no attempt to conceal
that she had been Crippen's mistress, but he protrayed her as a young innocent
who had been captured by the magnetic persoanlity of Crippen, describing her as
'this defenceless child' and a 'person without any knowledge of the world'.
Could she, he asked, have worn Cora's 'rising sun' brooch to the Criterion ball
had she known its owner had been murderered, or moved into Hilldrop Crescent
with this knowledge? The jury was out just 20 minutes, and Ethel Le Neve
was acquitted.
Lord Chief Justice Alverstone, who had also presided over Crippen's trial,
congratulated Smith. But Smith never heard a word of thanks from Ethel. |
 |
DR CRIPPEN AT MADAME TUSSAUDS :
With his wax effigy at Madame Tussauds on permanent display in the Chamber of
Horrors, Crippen gained the immortality Cora Crippen had so desperately wanted
as music-hall artiste Belle Elmore. |
|
|
Once convicted, Crippen was sent to Pentonville Prison, in north
London, to await the hangman. Her had only one real chance of the decision
being reversed, and that was at the appeal hearing on Friday 4th November.
Crippen allowed himself some optimism, but when the Criminal Court of Appeal
upheld his conviction, he gace up all hope.
Most of Crippen's time at Pentonville was spent thinking about Ethel Le Neve.
He wrote a dozen letters to her in the month between his conviction and
execution. Most of these were concerned with practical matters, such as
how she would cope financially after his death and whether she would take his
name in memory of him.
Crippen had savings deposited with the Charing Cross Bank and he wanted to
transfer these to Ethel. But the bank had used its funds to speculate in
land in Canada, and had lost everything. When the bank failed to open its
doors on 18th October (ironically, the day when his trial began), Crippen
realised he had probably lost all his money.
Le Neve wrote him letters in return, but in accordance with Crippen's
instructions, they were not kept. Along with his photograph of Ethel, they
were buried with him after his execution.
On the same day as Crippen's appeal, Ethel earned herself some money by posing
for a magazine called Lloyd's Weekly News. She agreed to dress up in the
same boy's outfit that she had worn during her escape aboard the Montrose.
To some, this was evidence of her insensitivity and proved that she did not care
about Crippen's fate. But she had already sold her life story to the same
publication with Crippen's approval. 'You have, my wifie, most ably set
forth important facts that must tell with great weight in the minds of the
unprejudiced,' he wrote to her. |
 |
CLOSED CARRIAGE OF DEATH :
A petition asking for Crippen to be spared the death sentence was sent to the
Home Office a week before his execution. It contained thousands of
signatures and the list grew daily. But it was to no avail, Winston
Churchill's decision was given to Crippen on 19th November. He was
transferred in a closed carriage to await execution. |
|
|
After the initial hostility to Crippen, the public mood began to
swing more and more towards sympathy as the date for his execution approached.
A number of petitions calling for Crippen's reprieve, with over 15,000
signatures, were delivered to the Home Office. His solicitor Arthur Newton
said that hundreds of other signatures were arriving daily. SOme of these
letters expressed doubts about the conviction - there was some concern that too
much of the evidence had been purely circumstantial.
On 18th November, Crippen's 83 year old father, Myron, died in Los Angeles.
he had been living in poverty for some months, since Crippen's flight had cut of
his remittance. The rooming housekeeper had allowed Myron to remain there
rent-free and a local restaurant had even sent him free meals. The
Coldwater Chronicle reported that his death had been hastened by grief over his
son's crime.
On 19th November, Winston Churchill, the Home Secretary who had been a spectator
during the Crippen/Le Neve trials, turned down Crippen's petition for a
reprieve. The news was delivered personally to Crippen in his cell by the
governor of Pentonville Prison, Major H. E. Mytton-Davies. The news was
given to Crippen late on Saturday, and the newspapers did not get the story
until the Monday.
Like Chief Inspector Dew before him, Mytton-Davis had developed a sympathy for
Crippen that bordered on friendship. He also personally delivered Ethel Le
Neve's final telegram at midnight on Tuesday 22nd November. When Crippen
saw the Major for the last time the next morning, he asked him to accept his set
of rosary beads and a ring, as a sign of appreciation for the consideration
shown to him. |
|
|
DR CRIPPEN & ETHEL LE NEVE :
United for posterity in the Chamber of Horrors, wax effigies of Dr Crippen and
Ethel Le Neve stand side by side. |
|
|
During the last few days the strain began to tell on Crippen.
Having shown a healthy appetite in the days leading up to the reprieve
application, he now began to look noticeably unwell. Two days before his
execution, Crippen worked out a plan to commit suicide. But one of the
warders noticed that part of his spectacles frame was missing and made a search
of Crippen's clothes.
While he was in the lavatory, Crippen had broken off the steel arm of his
spectacles and had hidden it in the inside seam at the bottom of his trouser
leg. Crippen had intended to puncture an artery and bleed slowly to death
while he slept on the eve of his execution.
Crippen saw Ethel Le Neve for the last time on 22nd November. On the
morning of Wednesday 23rd November 1910, he was hanged by the Chief Executioner,
James Ellis, assisted by William Willis. No bell rung because three other
prisoners were awaiting execution after Crippen. A notice was posted
outside the prison shortly after 9am where a large crowd was waiting.
While Crippen was being hanged, Ethel Le Neve, travelling as a Miss Allen, was
boarding the liner SS Majestic, bound for New York. |
 |
ETHEL LE NEVE HER LIFE STORY :
Le Neve sold her story to Lloyd's
Weekly News. The first installment appeared a fortnight after Crippen's
execution. The story later appeared in book form. |
|
|
Ethel Le Neve arrived in New York and from there moved to
Toronto, where she worked as a typist. In February 1911, she was granted
probate of Crippen's effects, amounting in value to £268. In 1916, she
returned to England to nurse her dying sister, Nina, living under the name of
Ethel Nelson. She married Stanley Smith, an accountant, and had a son and
daughter by him. Smith died in 1943 without having ever heard about her
relationship with Crippen. It was not until 1954 that she disclosed her
real identity to the novelist Ursula Bloom, who had written a book The Girl Who
Loved Crippen. Ethel's brother Sidney disclosed her whereabouts for the
sum of £30.
She died in Dulwich in 1967 at the age of 84. It is said that she asked
for a locket with a photograph of Crippen to be buried with her. |
 |
THE SPADE :
The spade which Crippen buried his wife's body in the coal cellar, and which
Chief Inspector Dew used to dig her up, is kept in London's Black Museum. |
|
|
Chief Inspector Walter Dew handed in his resignation the day
Crippen's appeal was turned down. He had become reasonably wealthy from
the damages he had won from the writs for libel he had issued against the
newspapers who suggested he had been negligent in allowing Crippen to escape.
One paper had paid £400 damages. He had set up a private detective agency
in Camberwell and died in 1947. |
 |
CAPTAIN KENDALL'S REWARD :
This cheque for
£250
from the Metropolitian Police was presented to Captain Kendall of the Montrose
as a reward for his detection work. The reward was authorised by the Home
Secretary, Winston Churchill. |
|
|
Henry Kendall, Captain of the Montrose, received £250 reward for his part in the
capture of Crippen. He was in command of the Empress of Ireland when she
sank on 29th May 1914, with a loss of 1062 lives - just off Father Point, where
Crippen had been arrested four years earlier. The Montrose herself was due
to be used as a block ship at the beginning of World War I. Breaking her
free from her moorings in December 1914, she ended up on the nortorious Goodwin
Sands, off Dover.
The book, film and theatre industry have
made a thriving trade out of the Crippen story. There have been no less
that 37 books written about the case, two films, a number of plays and even a
musical. |