shyscyberchamber.com  
UNSOLVED CRIMES

Date Added

Death in a Churchyard November 2002
  Nurse Olive Bennett was leading a double life... and it was to bring to her a violent death. For most of her adult life, forty-five year old Olive had lived in the prim, starchy style expected of a midwife and spinster. But since joining the staff of a maternity home at Tiddington, Warwickshire, she had begun to kick over the traces.


She had taken up smoking, and was making large withdrawals from her Post Office savings account. On her evenings off she would spend an hour or two dressing and making up and usually take the bus to nearby Stratford-Avon.


She became a familiar figure in the town's old-world pubs, chain smoking and drinking large sherries. She would often arrive back at the nurse's home by taxi in the early hours of the morning. Once she told a colleague she had been with her boyfriend.


So nothing seemed amiss when she was still not back by midnight on 23rd April 1954.


It was Shakespeare's 390th birthday, and all Stratford was celebrating. The Memorial Theatre was A Midsummer Night's Dream and restaurants and pubs were packed.


That night Olive caught the 20.15 bus to Stratford. Her first call was probably the Red Horse Hotel, where she was seen drinking until 21.00. She was seen later in other pubs. In one she said to a man: "I've had five schooners of sherry already. Aren't I a naughty girl?" The night porter at the Red Horse Hotel recalled seeing her again at 23.45 standing outside the hotel. He was the last man to see Olive alive.


Next morning the gardener at Holy Trinity Church beside the river noticed a headstone was missing. Nearby were a paid of spectacles, a woman's brown shoe and a set of lower dentures.


Within hours police had found Olive's body in the river, weighted down with the missing headstone. She had been strangled.


Her diary contained names of several men friends. All were questioned and eliminated from police enquiries. Every soldier at the nearby Long Marston camp was interviewed.


Scotland Yard was called in, and the legendary Detective Superintendent Jack Capstick - famed for his motto 'Softly, softly, catchee monkey' - arrived to head the case. Hundreds more people were questioned, but still the police drew a blank. Reluctantly, Capstick returned to the Yard leaving the case wide open.


Not until eight years later did two sisters come forward with a story that could be linked to murder. The girls, both bus conductresses, from Leamington Spa, said they had been in Stratford on the night of the murder and had been picked up by two soldiers. At 23.00 the four of them had gone for a walk in Holy Trinity churchyard.


The older girl said: 'We were standing by some graves when my soldier began getting fresh. I told him to stop it.' The soldier said, apparently as a joke, that he would push her into the river, with a headstone to weight her down.


The girls had kept quiet at the time because one was married, and the other did not want her mother to know. Perhaps if they had spoken up at the time Olive's murderer would have been found and brought to justice. The time lapse made it impossible.


Painstakingly the police traced and re-interviewed soldiers who had been at Long Marston camp at the time of the murder. Again, they drew a blank, and today it seems unlikely that the mystery of who killed Olive Bennett will ever be solved.

BACK TO TOP





Check out
the latest
Crypt Polls!
 


 

-»¦«-

F o u n d   a   b r  o k e n   l  i n k ?   L e t   u  s   k n o w